It really pains me to say this (as a long time fan of both director Robert Zemeckis and lead star Steve Carell) but Welcome to Marwen is an underdeveloped, unsettling mess full of grating characterizations and manipulative schmaltz.
Carell tried his best with a complicated role (further undercut by a woeful screenplay), but rather than evoking sympathy from the audience, his performance is considerably uncomfortable. The hate crime Mark endured isn’t near as fleshed out as it could’ve been, and…